About 70% of family businesses face significant challenges by the second generation of ownership, either failing or being sold. Planning for future leadership is important for any business, but it takes on a unique level of complexity when the enterprise is a family-owned one. Balancing the emotional ties, financial considerations, and future aspirations of multiple generations can be a daunting task. The absence of well-thought-out family business succession planning can lead to significant challenges, including family discord, financial instability, and the potential demise of the business itself.
“None of us know how long we have, and a clear succession plan is one of the greatest gifts we can leave our family.”
Mike Mirau, The Family Business Manifesto
Use this guide to explore options for a smooth transition to preserve the legacy of the family business. Here, we will dive into four primary options for succession, each with its own set of advantages and challenges.
Option 1: Passing the Torch to the Next Generation
“List all the various functions in your company. Who is responsible for each right now? Now, let’s do a mental exercise. If you weren’t here tomorrow, who would take over each role? You need a name to put for each function. That should be the person you intend to lead in that department at some point in the future.”
Mike Mirau, The Family Business Manifesto
Succession planning is often viewed as a distant future concern. However, the reality is far more immediate. A well-structured succession plan is not merely a strategic advantage; it’s a testament to a leader’s foresight and care for the family’s future. It’s important to start planning well in advance, ideally 5-10 years before the intended transition, to allow time to develop the skills and experience of the next generation. Involve the family as early as possible, and start documenting a formal, written succession plan.
The absence of a plan can have catastrophic consequences for family businesses. Without a clear roadmap, the risk of conflict, disunity, and even the dissolution of the business is significantly increased. Creating a pipeline of talent within the family can be a powerful strategy. By providing opportunities for education, training, and mentorship, you can cultivate the next generation of leaders that’s ready to take on the task when the time comes. A gradual transition, where the successor takes on increasing responsibilities over time under ongoing mentorship, can help build confidence and ensure a smooth handover.
“I know how hard it is to face mortality. But as the family business leader, you have to have the courage to change what needs to be changed and to prepare for a future without you. And you have to do it now. If you don’t, you risk making your loss even more difficult for your family. Leaving the business behind without a succession plan can create massive potential for fighting amongst family members. If no one knows who should take over and no one is prepared to take over, everyone can start fighting for the top position while no one is actually ready for it. That kind of chaos can destroy a business and a family.”
Mike Mirau, The Family Business Manifesto
Ensuring a Smooth Transition:
To make the change (and what follows) as smooth as possible, be proactive about improving:
- Governance Structure: Set up a clear governance structure, such as a family council or board of directors, to oversee the transition and provide guidance. This helps separate family dynamics from business decisions and ensures accountability.
- Open Communication: Foster open and transparent communication within the family and the business. Encourage regular discussions about the business’s future, succession plans, and any challenges that arise.
- Conflict Resolution: Establish mechanisms for resolving conflicts, such as mediation or third-party advisors. This can help address disagreements constructively and maintain family harmony.
- Legal Documentation: Ensure all legal aspects of the transition are in place, including wills, trusts, buy-sell agreements, and any other relevant documents. Consult with legal and financial advisors to ensure compliance and protect the interests of all parties involved.
- Tax Planning: Work with tax advisors to plan for the potential tax implications of transferring ownership. Strategies such as gifting shares, setting up trusts, or leveraging tax exemptions can help minimize tax liabilities.
- Financial Health: Ensure the business is financially healthy and stable before the transition. Address any outstanding debts, streamline operations, and build a strong financial foundation for the next generation.
By following these best practices, families can facilitate a smooth and successful transition of their business to the next generation, ensuring its continued growth and success while maintaining family harmony.
Go here to learn more about building a strong family business strategy.
Option 2: If Family Business Succession Planning is Too Complex, You Can Sell
Selling a family business can be a complicated and emotionally charged decision. While it may not be the ideal outcome for every family, you do need to consider all options. If selling sounds like a reasonable option to you, here are some things you need to consider:
- Financial Implications Selling a family business can offer significant financial rewards. You must get a good handle on the business’s value and understand the potential tax implications to know how much is really on the table. Distributing the proceeds among family members equitably can also be challenging.
- Emotional Implications Beyond the financial aspects, selling a family business can have profound emotional consequences. The decision to sell often evokes a sense of loss, as it represents the end of a chapter in the family’s history. Family dynamics can be impacted by disagreements about the sale or how the proceeds should be divided.
- Operational Implications A smooth transition of operations, knowledge, and customer relationships to the new owners is essential. The sale may also impact employees, including family members, requiring careful planning for their roles and well-being. Moreover, the new owners may introduce changes that could affect the business’s culture and continuity.
- Legal and Logistical Steps The selling process involves several legal and logistical steps, including due diligence,negotiations, and regulatory compliance. Seeking professional guidance from business brokers, financial advisors, and legal experts is highly recommended.
Option 3: Bringing in Outside Management
Hiring an outside manager can offer a fresh perspective and expertise to a family-owned business. This option can be particularly appealing when there isn’t a clear successor within the family or when the current leadership desires to step back from day-to-day operations.
- Benefits An outside manager can bring professional management skills, objectivity, and a focus on growth. They can also play a role in succession planning, preparing the next generation for leadership roles. Additionally, they may introduce innovative practices to improve efficiency and competitiveness.
- Challenges Integrating an outsider into a family-owned business can be a bumpy road. Cultural fit is vital, as is managing potential resistance to change from long-time employees and family members. Work diligently to establishing trust and authority for the new manager. Effective communication is key to aligning expectations and goals.
- Steps to Ensure Success To maximize the benefits of bringing in an outside manager, develop a clear plan.Define the manager’s role, conduct a thorough search for the right candidate, and provide comprehensive onboarding and support. Maintaining open communication and involving the family in strategic decisions while allowing the manager to handle day-to-day operations is also important.
Option 4: Skip Family Business Succession Planning and Shut it Down Instead
While it’s often a last resort, closing a family business may sometimes be the only viable option in some cases. It’s never an easy choice, but it may be the only path forward if the business is no longer sustainable.
- Financial Implications Closing a business involves significant financial considerations. Settling outstanding debts,liquidating assets, and understanding the potential tax implications are crucial steps. Distributing the remaining funds among family members is likely to take skilled negotiation to create a fair outcome.
- Legal and Administrative Steps There are numerous legal and administrative tasks involved in shutting down a business. Maintain integrity and safeguard your future business opportunities by complying with state regulations, notifying creditors and employees, and handling final contracts. Maintaining proper business records for the required period after closing the business is important.
- Emotional Implications Shutting down a family business can have a profound emotional impact on family members. It may lead to feelings of loss, identity crisis, and disrupted family dynamics. Plan to provide support and resources to help family members cope with these challenges.
- Operational Implications Winding down operations, managing customer and supplier relationships, and planning for employees’ futures are important operational considerations.
- Steps to Ensure a Smooth Shutdown To minimize disruptions and maximize the value of assets, seeking professional guidance from legal, financial, and tax advisors is highly recommended. Clear communication with all stakeholders will help with a smoother shutdown.
Family-Owned Business Succession Planning with Family CEOs
Succession planning involves understanding your options and taking proactive measures to promote a smooth transition and preserve your legacy.
Ready to secure the future of your family business? Contact Family CEOs, a peer advisory group designed to help family business leaders navigate complex challenges like succession planning.
